Crime #015 · Form teardown
Why shorter forms aren’t always better
Cutting fields can leave a form unable to deliver what its button promises. Here is how to tell which fields to keep.
The crime: cutting the fields visitors came to fill in
Long-standing advice says shorter forms convert better. So it is tempting to cut every field that does not look essential.
But some fields are the reason a visitor fills in the form. Remove them and the form no longer looks like it can deliver what the button promises.
This can happen on any form: a booking form, an enquiry form, a sign-up form. To show it, here is one example, cut right back to make the point clear. It is illustrative, and the firm is invented: a request-a-quote form on an accounting firm’s website that asks only for name, phone and email.
Why it fails
Picture a business owner on that firm’s site who wants to know what their accounts will cost. They click “Get my quote” and see this form.
They ask themselves a simple question. How can anyone price my work from my name and phone number?
Nobody can. So the visitor works out what will really happen next. Someone will ring them. The call will be a sales pitch, and the price will come at the end of it, if at all.
The button promised a quote. The form suggests a salesperson. That gap costs booked calls. Visitors who wanted a figure leave. The ones who stay arrive expecting to be sold to.
Swap in any other promise and the same gap opens up. A booking form that never asks about the visitor’s problem makes the same mistake. So does an enquiry form with no room to say what the enquiry is about.
The evidence
Others have seen the same effect in testing. Michael Aagaard, then a senior conversion optimiser at Unbounce, cut a client’s form from nine fields to six. Conversions fell by about 14%.
When he looked closer, he found he had removed the fields people actually wanted to fill in. The fields left behind were the ones they cared about least. (Source: CXL, “Should you reduce form fields?”)
The fix: ask for what the promise needs
Here is the same form, rebuilt around the promise on the button.
Version B is longer. It also feels like it will produce a quote, because the firm is asking for what it needs to price the work. The visitor can see how each question connects to the figure they want.
Notice what Version B leaves out. There is no “How did you hear about us?” question. That question serves the firm and does nothing for the visitor. Ask it on the call.
The field test
Judge every field by one question: does it get the visitor closer to what the button promises?
- If it does: Keep it, even if the form gets longer.
- If it only serves the firm: Remove it.
Two small details finish the job. Keep the consent wording short and plain. One sentence on how you will use their details is enough. Then say what happens after they submit, and when. For a quote form, that could mean saying the quote arrives by email within two working days. A visitor who knows what comes next has a reason to press the button.
Where this sits in the Buyable Model
In the Buyable Model this is an Act failure, and partly a Believe failure. The form is the last step before the visitor acts. It has to make that step feel worth taking. When it asks for the wrong things, the visitor stops believing the promise on the button.
Check your own form
- Step 1: Read your button. Write down exactly what it promises.
- Step 2: Go through each field. Ask whether it helps deliver that promise. Mark the ones that only help you.
- Step 3: Remove the marked fields and add any the promise needs. Then add one plain line on consent and one on what happens next.
Are you guilty of Crime #015?
Our Conversion System builds Book a Call funnels that make every step feel worth taking, the form included. Find out if your business qualifies.
Takes 60 seconds, instant result.